Illustration by J.R.R. Tolkien |
Lauterbrunnental in Switzerland |
---|
Beyond the amazing similarities of the images, Mr. Salo is a Tolkien linguistic scholor and draws his conclusion from several similarities of the names Tolkien uses to the name of the valley and that Tolkien specifically states (in The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, #306) that "The hobbit's (Bilbo's) journey from Rivendell to the other side of the Misty Mountains... is based on my adventures in 1911..." Although Tolkien does not specifically identify the Lauterbrunnental, apparently he did travel in this valley during his 1911 (aged 19) travels in Switzerland.
Marie Barnfield writes to tell me that she drew this conclusion (earlier and independently) some years ago in the 1990's and published an article in a Tolkien Society publication entitled The Lyfe ant the Auncestrye noting:
She also notes:
"I never got round to another article, but the Lauterbrunnen!
valley appears again in Lord of the Rings as the valley of the Snowbourne in
Rohan, with the Wengen area, and the Eiger, Monch and Jungrfrau, becoming
respectively Dunharrow, and the three mountains at their back of which one was
the haunted Dwimmorberg. If you sit and look at the valley walls from the
Breithorn campsite, I swear you can see the Pukel-road."
I am entirely convinced and find this fascinating, particularly as I am part Swiss. I finally, after some 25 years, got a chance to visit Lauterbrunnen in 2024 and it lives up to the billing! Thank you, David and Marie!
Alternatively, you can sign in to the House's Guestbook.